Monday, March 29, 2010

Put your comments on Bryan Caplan here

I suspect Bryan is most likely to reply on his own blog, EconLog.

34 comments:

burger flipper said...

Caplan may seem the most congenial and innocuous of the GMU mafia, but truthfully he is as evil and you label Roissy.

Andrew said...

Just because your parents aren't your fault doesn't make them my fault.

Justin Martyr said...

You don't see a difference between a single mother and a widow? I think they are both God's children and equally deserving of love, but I also think the former has made bad choices in her life whereas the latter has not. We do want to address the root causes of poverty, don't we?

And does this mean you think the 1996 reform to SSI, which removed alcoholics and drug addicts from those who were eligible from disability benefits, was a bad idea? Should it be reversed?

When you get right down to it, the whole justification for in-kind benefits over cash is predicated on the idea that people who need help often make bad choices. Would you favor eliminating in-kind transfers and simply giving the poor cash? Do you predict that this would help the poor achieve the full human flourishing? Or would it enable them to stray farther from the path to the good life?

Lord said...

Yes, because monitoring 300 million people is sooo much easier than a couple thousand insurers and providers. Perhaps camps with "Work makes free" signs on their entrances would be next.

Faré said...

Your parents ARE your fault. Inasmuch as you ARE indeed those genes, whatever those genes are are YOU, and whatever consequences they have are YOUR fault.

If we are to dismiss genetic causes because they are genetic, and environmental causes because they are environmental, what remains as causes?

People who deny causation live in a chaotic universe without logic. And then they worship force, the only thing they know, as the universal tool to solve all problems.

Michael said...

The word deserving is problematic in a symantic way but let's not play dumb. So much of a person's a product of their genetic makeup, who their parents were and what resources were provided to them. Agency cannot be seperated cleanly from the organism and likely cannot be seperated at all.

None of this means that we shouldn't create incentives for behavior that improves the collective welfare. Even if murderers are cursed with defective genes and abusive parents doesn't mean that imposing a penalty for murder is a bad idea.

John Goodman said...

The better answer is to give each individual or family the same subsidy -- for insurance and Health Savings Accounts if they choose or to a local safety net institution if they elect to be uninsured.

Let a free market for risk decide what risks are worth what price, let charitable insititions determine who is otherwise deserving or not, and allow the kind of insurance that is personal and portable -- so that the problems of pre-existing conditions don't plague people after they get sick.

Mitch said...

What Michael said. Even if we could explain a murderer's behavior in terms of nature, or nurture, or both, what does that mean for how we deal with them?

Should we say, "Oh, he has genetic variants associated with psychopathy; clearly his behavior isn't his fault. Set him free!" Um, no. Lock him the heck up! Those deserts are entirely just and consistent.

Justin Irving said...

Eating meat does not cause heart disease, see http://www.paleonu.com/ if you doubt this. Otherwise the point is valid, I feel compelled to fight this common diet error.

Anonymous said...

Tyler, your argument is no different than saying there is no free will in the libertarian sense, therefore nobody is respopnsible for being a criminal, etc... therefore we shouldn't punish people, etc...

Anonymous said...

It seems to me the point Mitch makes could be a pretty good justification for capital punishment as opposed to leniency(weed out the bad genes).

Philo said...

"This is a fundamental tension in Caplanian thought, namely the desire to promote intuitions of both meritocracy/desert and facts about heritability." (1) It's not just in *Caplanian* thought: doesn't *everyone* suffer from this "tension"? (2) Suppose you soft-pedal the heritability, admitting a large component of environmental influence; how does that help you save *desert*?

Michael Vassar said...

You can inherit desert. Most of us agree that most humans inherit the entitlement to be granted human rights etc. Many, especially in Europe where citizenship are automatically distributed along ethnic lines also think that people inherit the entitlement to citizenship. Europeans also inherit the right to inherit, as parents can't usually disown their children. Americans and Europeans agree that people inherit the right to the childcare care that a particular set of parents consider appropriate. Causality doesn't eliminate entitlement or blame, ever.

Jack Rodwell said...

It's a silly argument that doesn't really deserve to be taken seriously. Just because things are heritable doesn't mean we don't have to take responsibility for our actions.

Anonymous said...

Anonymous@1:34PM Sterilization seems like a more precise tool to achieve your goal. And that's exactly what we need ... a revival of eugenics. If it weren't for political correctness and those damn Nazis, things would be so much better in the US of A.

Andrew said...

As with most of these things, there is a bait and switch in the logical leap some people make here.

Would parental reparations fix the problem? No. Only gene therapies will fix the underlying problem.

The first socialist country that provides the world with gene therapies will get an apology from me.

We don't believe in meritocracy for the sake of meritocracy. We don't even believe in it because it's good for society. We believe in letting people alone because that way they will individually achieve their highest potential.

longge said...

Breitling Bentley dating aback to 1884 was founded by Leon Chronomat Evolution in the apple of St. Imier, Switzerland. Basking below the celebrity of a anon of time befitting tradition, The Chronomat B01 ancestors business underpinned on quality, adroitness and attention has acquired to be a apple baton in high- end Superocean .
That is the additional appeal of Coach Wallets . You can always re-sell these, as long as Coach Ergo are still in mint condition. Coach Legacy started out as the family business in Manhattan. Six artisans were responsible for the handcrafted collection. This became them ark of the Coach Luggage .
Buying Hogan scarpe that are appropriate for the activity that will take place Hogan scarpe uomo is necessary for proper foot protection. Hogan scarpe donna are perfect for going to the beach though, since only the bottoms of feet need to be protected from the hot sand. Outdoor activities are much more enjoyable when the proper hogan donna actually fits correctly too.

Anonymous said...

Good People!
I was looking around for [url=http://www.milesgershon.com][b]Contemporary Entertainment Center[/b][/url] or [url=http://www.milesgershon.com][b]Contemporary Wall Units[/b][/url] (I'm not really sure what the difference is LoL) and was wondering if you know any resources to explain what I need to know to make an informed purchasing decision. Any review is appreciated.
Thanks in-advance

Mary

Check out the link to this article I found about [url=http://www.squidoo.com/ent3rtacn3tr][b]Entertainment Centers[/b][/url]

[url= http://www.milesgershon.com/entertainment-center.html][img] http://ep.yimg.com/ca/I/yhst-19364734663496_2071_606467 [/img][/url]

Anonymous said...

Assolutamente d'accordo con lei. Credo che questo sia un concetto molto diverso. Pienamente d'accordo con lei.
Condivido pienamente il suo punto di vista. In questo nulla in vi e 'una buona idea. Pronta a sostenere voi.

Anonymous said...

Aw, this was a unquestionably worth post. In theory I' d like to write like this too - prepossessing point and unfeigned toil to acquire a obedient article... but what can I say... I equivocate alot and conditions seem to put something done.
[IMG]http://www.sedonarapidweightloss.com/weightloss-diet/34/b/happy.gif[/IMG]

Buy Oriental Rugs Online said...

I totally agree.
Buy Oriental Rugs Online

Anonymous said...

sell GFaLpsSd [URL=http://www.camera--lenses.com/]canon 75-300 iii[/URL] online AkSARYHo [URL=http://www.camera--lenses.com/ ] http://www.camera--lenses.com/ [/URL]

Anonymous said...

This info is invaluable. How can I find out more?


Look into my blog - How To Buy A Car
Also visit my web page ; buying a car with bad credit,buy a car with bad credit,how to buy a car with bad credit,buying a car,buy a car,how to buy a car

Anonymous said...

I'm curious to find out what blog platform you have been working with? I'm
having some minor security problems with my latest website and I would like
to find something more safeguarded. Do you have any suggestions?


my web site Buy A car with Bad credit
Check out my site buying a car with bad credit,buy a car with bad credit,how to buy a car with bad credit,buying a car,buy a car,how to buy a car

Anonymous said...

Hi, Neat post. There's an issue together with your website in web explorer, could test this? IE nonetheless is the marketplace leader and a huge element of other people will leave out your magnificent writing due to this problem.

Feel free to visit my web-site ... buy a car with bad credit
My web site :: buying a car with bad credit,buy a car with bad credit,how to buy a car with bad credit,buying a car,buy a car,how to buy a car

Anonymous said...

Howdy! I'm at work browsing your blog from my new iphone 3gs! Just wanted to say I love reading through your blog and look forward to all your posts! Carry on the great work!

Stop by my weblog - buying a Car
My website > buying a car with bad credit,buy a car with bad credit,how to buy a car with bad credit,buying a car,buy a car,how to buy a car

Anonymous said...

view MzMSwPEr [URL=http://www.cheapguccireplica.tumblr.com/ - gucci online[/URL - at my estore zcPeCpXy [URL=http://www.cheapguccireplica.tumblr.com/ - http://www.cheapguccireplica.tumblr.com/ [/URL -

Anonymous said...

If you want to improve your know-how only keep visiting this web page and be updated with the most up-to-date gossip posted here.


Also visit my web-site: www.fb-fanseiten.eu
My web site > hexagon

Anonymous said...

get cIqhwNXK [URL=http://www.aaareplicahandbags.weebly.com/ - best designer bags[/URL - for less DYOGRZtv [URL=http://www.aaareplicahandbags.weebly.com/ - http://www.aaareplicahandbags.weebly.com/ [/URL -

Anonymous said...

check this link, sozUodxF [URL=http://www.cheapdesigner--handbags.weebly.com/ - discount designer handbags[/URL - to your friends mBWBuIWj [URL=http://www.cheapdesigner--handbags.weebly.com/ - http://www.cheapdesigner--handbags.weebly.com/ [/URL -

Anonymous said...

Youг current report offerѕ confirmed necesѕаrу to
us. It’s quite educational аnԁ уou rеally aгe natuгally reallу educаteԁ
іn this regіon. Yоu have got opened my persоnal facе in oгԁеr
to numerоus views оn this ρarticulаr mаttеr аlоng with inteгеstіng and sound
cоntent.

Alsо viѕit my blog ... ambien

Anonymous said...

Thе anѕwer іѕ easy, theгe аre
many exсеllent cаrloans 3 Series Coop and Cοnѵeгtіble looκs.
Υou gеt thе chancе to chip in
аnd buy a bгanԁ new oрeratіng ѕуstеm.
She wаѕ а Ladybug of сoursе!


mу ρage - sehl

Anonymous said...

If you think you mіght hаve saved on buses; all
that time Ι'd have saved on a Lexus or Infiniti. The government doesn't kiсκ you any rеbates or tax inсentіves for this ρlatform, so it is uр to you.
No longеr do I have?

Ϻу homepagе :: worldmeetmarket.com

Anonymous said...

dating sites prices http://loveepicentre.com/success_stories/ bdsm dating sites
service to distribute information dating provided [url=http://loveepicentre.com/taketour/]is lil wayne dating superhead[/url] cop dating site
dating a guy co worker tips [url=http://loveepicentre.com/faq/]dating pakistan asian singles[/url] single cogic for dating [url=http://loveepicentre.com/user/mary8641/]mary8641[/url] radiometric dating simulation